Find the right Medicare plan!
Learning Center / Medicare / Compare Nursing Home Options: A Practical Guide to Informed Decision Making

In this article


Compare Nursing Home Options: A Practical Guide to Informed Decision Making

July 26, 2023

Compare Nursing Home Options: A Practical Guide to Informed Decision Making

Choosing a nursing home for yourself or a loved one is a critical decision that requires careful research and consideration. There are various factors to take into account, ranging from the quality of care to the overall atmosphere of the facility. In this article, we will explore essential criteria to evaluate nursing homes, including the Medicare star rating, employee-to-resident ratios, fines, complaints, and other relevant aspects that should be considered to make an informed choice.

Medicare Star Rating:

The Medicare star rating system is a valuable tool provided by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). It rates nursing homes on a scale of one to five stars, with five being the highest rating. The overall rating is based on three components: health inspections, staffing levels, and quality measures. A higher star rating generally indicates a better overall performance. However, it's essential to look deeper into each component to gain a more comprehensive understanding.

Health Inspections:

Health inspections are crucial indicators of a nursing home's compliance with health and safety regulations. The inspection reports provide details about any deficiencies found during on-site visits. When evaluating a nursing home, review the inspection reports to identify patterns of recurring issues and the severity of violations.

Staffing Levels:

Employee-to-resident ratios are crucial in assessing the quality of care provided at a nursing home. Adequate staffing ensures residents receive the attention and assistance they need. Look for facilities with sufficient staff to accommodate the number of residents, as this contributes significantly to overall well-being and satisfaction.

Quality Measures:

Quality measures encompass various aspects of care, such as pain management, pressure ulcer rates, and vaccination rates. These metrics offer insights into the nursing home's performance in specific areas of resident health and well-being. A nursing home with consistently high-quality measures is likely to prioritize resident comfort and safety.

Fines and Penalties:

Pay attention to any fines or penalties imposed on the nursing homes by regulatory bodies. Frequent or severe fines may indicate underlying issues with the facility's operations or quality of care. A transparent and accountable facility will often take prompt action to rectify issues that lead to penalties.

Complaints and Resident Feedback:

Check for complaints lodged against the nursing home with the state's ombudsman office or the CMS. Pay attention to the nature and frequency of complaints and how the facility addressed them. Additionally, read reviews and testimonials from current and former residents and their families to gain insights into the overall resident experience.

Personal Visits:

While researching online and gathering data is essential, nothing can replace an in-person visit to the nursing homes you are considering. Schedule tours to observe the cleanliness, staff interactions with residents, and the general atmosphere of the facility. Engage with residents and their families if possible to gain first-hand accounts of their experiences.

Specialized Care:

If the prospective resident has specific medical needs or requires specialized care, ensure that the nursing home can accommodate those needs. Inquire about the availability of trained staff, specialized programs, and any relevant certifications.

CMS Nursing Home Compare Resources

There are several resources available to help users compare nursing homes and make informed decisions. These resources provide valuable information on different aspects of nursing home care, ratings, reviews, and more. Here are some of the top resources:

  1. Nursing Home Compare ( This is an official website by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) that allows users to search and compare nursing homes based on various criteria. It provides the Medicare star rating, health inspection reports, staffing data, quality measures, and more.


  1. Nursing Home Inspect (ProPublica): This platform allows users to search for nursing homes and view their inspection reports from CMS. It provides a user-friendly interface to explore inspection deficiencies and other relevant information.


  1. Eldercare Locator (Administration on Aging): This resource assists users in finding local services and resources for older adults, including nursing homes. It provides contact information for local agencies and organizations that can offer guidance and support.


State Department of Health Websites: Many state health departments have dedicated sections on their websites where users can find information on licensed nursing homes, inspection reports, complaints, and penalties imposed on facilities. Simply search for "nursing home resources" or "long-term care facilities" along with your state's name.

AARP Nursing Home Checklist: AARP offers a helpful nursing home checklist that guides users on what to look for during visits and how to assess the quality of care in a nursing home.


  1. Consumer Reports Nursing Home Ratings: Consumer Reports provides ratings and reviews of nursing homes based on factors like staffing, quality of care, and health inspections.


Local Ombudsman Offices: State and local ombudsman offices can be valuable resources to provide information about nursing home complaints and the quality of care in specific facilities. They can also offer advocacy and support.

Family and Friends: Reach out to friends, family members, or acquaintances who may have experience with specific nursing homes. Their insights and personal experiences can be invaluable in the decision-making process.

Remember to use multiple resources to gain a well-rounded perspective on nursing homes. Each source may offer slightly different information, and combining them can help users make the most informed decision possible. 


Choosing a nursing home is a decision that necessitates thorough research and evaluation. Consider multiple criteria, such as the Medicare star rating, health inspection reports, employee-to-resident ratios, fines, and complaints, to gain a comprehensive understanding of the facility's quality of care. In addition to data-driven assessments, personal visits and resident feedback are essential to ensure a suitable and nurturing environment for your loved one. By taking the time to research and evaluate nursing homes thoroughly, you can make a well-informed decision and provide your loved one with the best possible care.

© 2021-2023, LLC

Privacy Policy  |  Terms and Conditions

GENERAL DISCLAIMERS is a commercial site designed for the solicitation of insurance from selected health insurance carriers and, LLC is a licensed insurance agency. It is not a government agency. It is also not an insurer, or a medical provider., LLC is a licensed representative of Medicare Advantage (HMO, PPO, PFFS, and PDP) organizations that have a Medicare contract. Enrollment depends on the plan’s contract renewal.
We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent nine carrier plan organizations nationally. Please contact, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options.
Alternatively, you may be referred, via a link, to a selected partner website, which is independently owned and operated and may have different privacy and terms of use policies from us.
If you provide your contact information to us, an insurance agent/producer or insurance company may contact you. If you do not speak English, language assistance service, free of charge, is available to you; contact the toll-free number listed above. This site is not maintained by or affiliated with the federal government's Health Insurance Marketplace website or any state government health insurance marketplace.
The plans we represent do not discriminate on the basis of race, color, national origin, age, disability, or sex. To learn more about a plan's nondiscrimination policy, please click here.